Well F*ck me, I had 2 issues!
Used the java uninstaller from the program files folder. Installed RR 0.7.2 (I think it was 0.7.0 before?)
And got this:
13502 INFO [Thread-6] - Re-trying previous J2534/ISO9141 connection: Tactrix Inc. - OpenPort 2.0 J2534 ISO/CAN/VPW/PWM
13538 INFO [Thread-6] - J2534 Version => firmware: 1.16.4819, dll: 1.02.4820 Jul 6 2016 17:20:04, api: 04.04
13549 DEBUG [Thread-6] - J2534/ISO9141 set connection properties: bits=8, parity=0
13551 DEBUG [Thread-6] - J2534/ISO9141 success: deviceId:3, channelId:5, msgId:0
13554 INFO [Thread-6] - J2534/ISO9141 connection initialised
13557 DEBUG [Thread-6] - ECU Init Request ---> 8010F001BF40
*multiple skipped lines*
15599 DEBUG [Thread-6] - Error sending init
Since the new error I looked further into the connections, I have one weak pin in my car's OBD2 port as well!
In hindsight though, it would be awesome to choose J2534 devices the same way we could COM ports